OpenSolaris Elections
10 Mar '07 - 03:49 by benrOpenSolaris will hold its first major community wide election next week, with voting opening on March 12th. The voting system is currently open now for testing, please take this opportunity to familiarize yourself with the system and help test it now.
The voting system is pretty simple but may be a bit odd at first. You simply create an SSH key pair (ssh-keygen) and add that public key to your OpenSolaris Profile page. You can add up to 3 keys so I added both my dsa and rsa keys. Once you've done that just ssh poll.opensolaris.org and start voting:
benr@ben-rockwoods-computer .ssh$ ssh poll.opensolaris.org
Last login: Fri Mar 9 23:10:59 2007 from c-24-6-105-152.
opensolaris.org Vote Recorder (poll)
You may enter "help" or "quit" at any prompt. Links to further
instructions are provided at http://poll.opensolaris.org/
USER: Ben Rockwood (benr)
GRANT: CONTRIBUTOR, cab, expiring Tue Feb 24 00:32:45 2009
GRANT: CORE CONTRIBUTOR, documentation, expiring Tue Feb 24 00:32:45 2009
GRANT: CORE CONTRIBUTOR, immigrants, expiring Tue Feb 24 00:32:45 2009
GRANT: CORE CONTRIBUTOR, marketing, expiring Tue Feb 24 00:32:45 2009
POLL 1: Community Priorities/Polling Test
This poll of Core Contributors serves both to test the polling
system prior to the Board Election, and to collect Community
priorities as input for the next Board's planning.
Place as many of the items as you wish to vote for into your order
of preference. The voting system will use your list of chosen items
and order of preference to determine the winners of the vote using
the Meek variant[2] of the Single Transferable Vote[1] system.
[1] STV see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Transferable_Vote
[2] Meek algorithm see http://sourceforge.net/projects/votesystem/
QUESTION 1.1: ("Priorities") Which of the following items, presented
in a randomized order, should be prioritized by the Governing Board in
order to promote OpenSolaris and increase its developer mindshare?
1 - Deploy a public code review facility on opensolaris.org
('Code_Review')
2 - Provide a SPARC-based kernel/project build facility
('SPARC_Build')
3 - Deploy a public defect management system ('Defect_Mgmt')
4 - Remove inactive Communities or Projects ('Remove_Inactive')
5 - Eliminate reliability issues with opensolaris.org web pages
('Reliability')
6 - Replace opensolaris.org tools with an open source CMS or wiki
('New_CMS')
7 - Deploy a public Request To Integrate (RTI) system ('RTI')
8 - Provide an x86/AMD64-based kernel/project build facility
('X64_Build')
9 - Replace or remove Jive forum interface ('No_Jive')
10 - Deploy a public wiki on opensolaris.org ('Wiki')
11 - Reorganize the existing Community/Project organization
('Reorganize_Community')
12 - Create an infrastructure project to run opensolaris.org
('Infrastructure')
This question is being resolved by single transferable vote. Please enter
a space separated list of your candidates, ordered by preference. You
may omit candidates.
RESPONSE 1.1 --> 1 3 11 10 4
VERIFY: Your ballot is:
Priorities: [Code_Review Defect_Mgmt Reorganize_Community Wiki Remove_Inactive ]
COMMIT BALLOT (y/n) --> y
RECORDED: ballot on "Community Priorities/Polling Test" from Ben Rockwood
Connection to poll.opensolaris.org closed.
benr@ben-rockwoods-computer .ssh$
Pretty easy. Stephen Hahn and crew did a good job with it and I think it'll work well when people get the hang of it.
When it come time to vote next week, starting March 12th, you'll be asked to vote on two things: ratification of the Draft Constitution and election of a new OpenSolaris Governing Board (OGB).
Before you vote I urge you to read and familiarize yourself with the Draft Constitution and particularly asked yourself whether or not it fulfills the requirements set forth by the OpenSolaris Charter. Its a lot to read I know, and its pretty dry and in some cases confusing stuff, but the effort will be well worth it and really be a service to the community as a whole.
The Constitution defines the OGB as consisting of between 3 and 7 persons. We have 19 Canidates currently so it looks like we'll have a full OGB of 7 persons.
Each and every one of the canidates is worthy of the post and would bring unique qualities to the table, but I want to especially highlight 3 people which I feel strongly about:
- Michelle Olson: Michelle is one of the leaders of the Documentation Community and a powerful asset within the OpenSolaris Community. She is always interested in community affairs with an attentive ear toward everyone and is not quick to judge. She regularly attends meetings of the Silicon Valley OpenSolaris Users Group, has helped out at a variety of OpenSolaris community functions including LinuxWorld, and has helped drive community outreach with programs like the OpenSolaris Starter Kit. She is fair and kind and provides a much needed "beyond the code" view of the project. It would be a tragedy to not have her on the board.
- Keith M Wesolowski: Keith wrote the Charter and set the tone for the Constitution although much of his input and suggestions were left out of the evolving drafts. No one knows the issues like Keith! He always keeps the issues in perspective and has the big picture in mind. Simply put, Keith has real vision of the project and the real world know-how to drive this project forward.
- Stephen Lau: Stephen is absolutely committed to OpenSolaris and has been one of the hands that has made it successful to date. His experience working behind the scenes provides a powerful real-world insight into whats really needed and what does and doesn't work. Stephen is involved in almost every aspect of the effort which brings even more to the table. On a board you need people with experience, passion, and ideals, and Stephen brings all three with him.
You can read each of these nominees positions on the election page. Please carefully consider putting these 3 people at the top of your list.
When turning your attention to the ratification, there are a great number of things to consider. I won't get into the nitty-gritty, but I'll throw out some things to think about:
- Do you want an OGB that involved in day-to-day issues or passive until needed?
- Should the Constitution be explicit in the structure of the organization or stay as general as possible so as to be later defined by other bodies (ie: the Dev Process)
- Should governance within Communities (called "Community Groups" in the draft) be allowed to governed however they choose or should it be stipulated for them?
- Are the Draft defined classes of membership (ie: "Roles") sufficient and appropriate? (ie: Participant, Contrib, Core Contrib, Emeritus Contrib)
- Should the OGB have say into code matters?
- etc, etc, etc.
I forward to opinion on these things, I've spoken out on many of them in the past, but I offer them as a starting point for those who might feel overwhelmed by reviewing the Draft quickly prior to the vote. How do you feel? Are your feelings reflected in the current draft? Does it leave adequate room for you view to be applicable later?
There are many ways to view a constitution. When we started working on drafts I spent weeks reading every constitution I could get my hands on and trying to determine what one really is. As the process evolved the general consensus seemed to be that the purpose of the OpenSolaris constitution was to frame the social organization and to leave the technical organization to the Dev Process which would follow once the Constitution was ratified. In general you can view the current constitution as providing boundaries: how do you start it, deal with it, and kill it. The idea being to allow as much definition and redefinition within later resolutions as possible so as to form a more flexible organization. Depending on your point of view this can be good or bad, but I will say that I learned early on to let go of solidifying everything within the Constitution itself. Erroring on the side of flexibility is preferable to forcing a later amendment. In general my mindset became "don't write it to be re-written by someone else".
As to my personal input into the current draft, while I was very active in early drafts most of my direct contributions have been molded in or left out over time. On the Genunix Wiki, where the writing was done, you can see many of my edits and comments in the early draft. I will admit that the "7.5 Facilitator" was basically my fault and as written is not what I intended. I'm a proponent of a strong and rigid structure and originally called for each community to elect a "Community Lead" who would be the final responsible party for that community rather than just leaving things up to whichever Core Contrib felt like handling things (calling votes, communicating with the OGB, formally accepting proposals, etc). In essense I actually wanted things work work under the system of Parliamentary Order wherein each Community would be required to elect of their own accord (drawing straws, choosing amongst themselves, voting, whatever) both a secretary and a chair person... but those ideas got dumbed down into an Ambassador and then to a Facilitator. So anyway, if you read 7.5 and want to blame someone, you can point the finger my way. Sorry 'bout that.
Of course, I'm nominated for the board myself. This is the second time I've been nominated (I finished 3rd in the election of the 2 current community seats) and I'm honored to be on the ballot. Beyond what I've posted I'm not planning an election campaign or position papers. My opinions are out there, many people know them and others can find them on the CAB lists. In general I advocate a strong organization with clear delineations. I'm hopeful for the future and doing everything I can to make it a brighter one. I'm Director of Systems at Joyent where we're running OpenSolaris in production for everything that we do and providing it directly to customers via our Accelerator product. I view my day job as an extension of my duties to the OpenSolaris Project itself and I'm proud of what I'm doing for OpenSolaris evangelism and feel that its important that for someone at a company like Joyent who is on the front lines with OpenSolaris to be an active part of the community itself. Whether I'm on the board or not, I'm working hard for the project every day in one way or another and that won't stop.
Wouldn’t that be adding the ssh public key. Just on the off chance somebody doesn’t know ssh keys that well.
sfire||mouse - 10 March '07 - 14:36
Of course I preview my posts and correct errors… what makes you think I don’t?(fixed, thanks mouse :))
benr - 11 March '07 - 00:18
Your suggestions were not the background for the Facillitator role—it is directly from the PMC chair position at Apache (each community at Apache has a chair that also serves as a VP officer and reports to the ASF board). I am the PMC chair for Apache HTTP Server.It is not a good idea to talk about this person as the community leader, or one who is responsible for decisions and/or governance, since that leads to communities that will die as soon as that person loses interest. The role is specifically intended to guide the community in making decisions. I chose the name “Facillitator” because it more accurately reflects the role in an organization that does not have legal responsibilities.
I know the concept of “Lead” from Linux and deliberately avoided including it in the governance because the expressed desire was for a governance model that included the community as equals. With Leads, nobody outside Sun would ever be able to lead a development community. With a Facillitator, anyone doing the work leads a development community.
In general, writing the constitution would have been a lot easier if the main participants in Solaris had been more honest about what they wanted in a governance model. The easy path would have been to simply replicate the Linux model with the gateway maintainers being benevolent dictators. What you see in the constitution is the Apache model because people outside the engineering group did not want a model that would reflect the status quo in engineering. The business justification for making OpenSolaris was to involve the community as peers, not as supplicants.
Roy T. Fielding (Email) (URL) - 13 March '07 - 13:16
09459eba ffae2455 568 ancor1|ancor2|ancor3|ancor4|ancor5 They are simply looking for a better [URL= [[http://google3.com.com]] ]ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5[/URL] .If you were to ask ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 : what are you doing out here?
Gods Angels God asked his [[http://google3.com.org]] ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 search : Why do you look so sad?
Hello people! Nice site!
Bertha (Email) (URL) - 13 May '08 - 03:46
09459eba ffae2455 568 ancor1|ancor2|ancor3|ancor4|ancor5 It seems to me he made the cave larger in the [URL= [[http://google2.com.com]] ]ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5[/URL] .Only noblemen were permitted to hunt with ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 .
[[http://google2.com.org]] Hot ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 round out the eighth and ninth positions.
You have built a good website
Rebekah (Email) (URL) - 13 May '08 - 04:53
09459eba ffae2455 568 ancor1|ancor2|ancor3|ancor4|ancor5 Gods Angels God asked his [URL= [[http://google1.com.com]] ]ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 search[/URL] : Why do you look so sad?They are simply looking for a better ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 .
I gave him the [[http://google1.com.org]] ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 information one day, and he was so happy.
Cool!.. Nice work…
Sam (Email) (URL) - 13 May '08 - 19:46
09459eba ffae2455 568 ancor1|ancor2|ancor3|ancor4|ancor5 I gave him the [URL= [[http://google1.com.com]] ]ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 information[/URL] one day, and he was so happy.On Venus he discovered free ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 primitively bestial, and advanced as well.
Only noblemen were permitted to hunt with [[http://google1.com.org]] ancor1ancor2ancor3ancor4ancor5 .
Oh o ho! very nice site!
Sebastien (Email) (URL) - 14 May '08 - 10:24
shop zithromax welcomezithromax (Email) (URL) - 15 May '08 - 06:29
teenyteeny (Email) (URL) - 16 May '08 - 00:18
xanaxxanax (Email) (URL) - 20 May '08 - 10:35
xanaxxanax (Email) (URL) - 21 May '08 - 04:01
blodulvblodulv (Email) (URL) - 24 May '08 - 01:01
university of arkansas fort smithrules of rithmomachia
feechka-ay (Email) (URL) - 06 August '08 - 02:22
meters and centimeters hahnemann unversity hospital careers ameraprise song jewelry columbus ohio dictonary dementedmelanie wills clinique song surfcasting for striped bass internal revenue service atlanta stephanie gorin
nanny_[!2] (Email) (URL) - 11 October '08 - 13:17
open alcoholic beverage las vegas outfit xbox360 jesse mccarthey neveada drivers ed pound cake mix recipemother and baby fairy pictures in ink and pen nascarraces in what direction does the moon rise electro tours of homes in pasco county florida nokia 6255i phone case
nanny_[!2] (Email) (URL) - 11 October '08 - 20:24
colliershawaii com red robin burgers websites for transporting services needing independent contractors hersam acorn newspapers forbes symptoms of ketosisreal estsate louterneau jimmy chew pet toy san francisco academy of sciences pvc threaded fittings
feechka-gb (Email) (URL) - 12 October '08 - 21:23
galen medical group professional writing services for cover letters camletoes little rock free press i needs a love lyricsmoma waitress the windjammer and sc chewyvuitton pet toy tom cruise tv tome carabao
nanny_[!2] (Email) (URL) - 12 October '08 - 22:42
comic babe models john maddock & sons fortify software michael ealy gossp to go with floexcelsior 20college whatswrong comic babes homes for rent in reno golfsouthconferenceseniorbowl
feechka-py (Email) (URL) - 13 October '08 - 10:39
highland towers birmingham st john the divine gift shop bright eyes party lyrics wrthomas sleeping quotescontractor tradesmen insurance coverage the song of bernadette production photos lasalle apartment ratings birmingham how to become a cellulad phone dealer university cincinnati
nanny_[!2] (Email) (URL) - 13 October '08 - 13:09
ohio sate and wbns-tv terrestrial radio using too much accu-clear makes water more cloudy in fish tank books about kim philby the honeycombsfree nude picturs u of a softball schedule trollz code dyy86qk3wmc641m1y personilize desk plate knso
nanny_[!2] (Email) (URL) - 13 October '08 - 19:54
dri residential injured parakeets preaning sonoco storage tubes the mecklenburg sun usmcrstacey deffenbaugh baynetwork tab trenyce and american idol free grands without payback peigle
nanny_[!2] (Email) (URL) - 14 October '08 - 02:51
Very interesting article: “OpenSolaris Elections”Etta (Email) (URL) - 23 January '09 - 17:22
It was a very nice idea! Just wanna say thank you for the information you have shared. Just continue writing this kind of post. I will be your loyal reader. Thanks again.Christian louboutin shoes (Email) (URL) - 27 October '09 - 03:23
Thank you very much!ed hardy clothing (Email) (URL) - 09 November '09 - 00:55
Great post! Hope to be better. Better means more features.good post,I think so!
Thanks for your information, i have read it, very good！
Bing is a really overlord!! support Bing~~
This is great news. Best of luck for the future and keep up the good work.
tiffany and co (Email) (URL) - 19 November '09 - 01:28
Just one question: how to add your blog into my rrs reader, thanks so much.christian louboutin (Email) (URL) - 03 January '10 - 07:07
Good post! Thanks you for your information! China Wholesale Wholesale China Wholesalers Wholesale Game Accessories Wholesale Iphone Accessories Video Game Accessories Wholesale Wholesale Wii Accessories Wholesale Xbox 360 Accessories Wholesale Xbox 360 Games Wholesale Video Games Cheap Video Games Cheap Ps3 Games Cheap Xbox 360 Games Wholesale Computers Wholesale Laptop Computers Wholesale Laptops Discount Computers Cheap Computers Wholesale Iphones Wholesale Iphone Wholesale Iphones 3g Hiphones Wholesale Hiphone Wholesale Hiphones Wholesale Nokia Wholesale Nokia 8800 Wholesale Nokia n97 wholesale blackberry wholesale blackberry phones wholesale blackberry 9700 wholesale blackberry 9600 wholesale blackberry 9500raging bull (Email) (URL) - 15 January '10 - 06:47
I will make sure and bookmark this page, I will come back to follow you more.hickory nc furniture (Email) (URL) - 25 January '10 - 19:16
Good post! Thanks for your information! As Seen On TVAs Seen On TV (Email) (URL) - 30 January '10 - 06:16
abercrombie and fitch [[http://www.abercrombieonsale.com]]tiffany (Email) (URL) - 03 March '10 - 06:21
i agree with youghd hair straighteners (Email) (URL) - 19 April '10 - 02:53
I very intersted in the articlecheap mbt shoes (Email) (URL) - 23 April '10 - 03:42
I’m a little late finding this article, but I loved it.As we know, now sunglasses are loved by more and more people, and everyone would like to have a pair of comfortable sunglasses,save up to 47%.welcome to [[http://www.eyewear-rayban.com]]
rayban sunglasses (Email) (URL) - 29 April '10 - 07:17
P90x .It really is not expensive if you factor in the costof a gym membership,P90x workout . The cost for P90X is
about three months of a paid gym membership but you get to
keep the program foreverP90x . You can try many of the
online sites, but it will be the same as buying from the
company or a Beachbody Coach. Make sure you are getting
original DVD’s. People are selling copies all over. The
problem is how long will they last, P90x workout ,and you
truly need the exercise and nutrition guide to even follow
the program. You can go to any site or you can go to
[[http://www.p90xmall.com]] and click on products. P90x dvd You can
order directly from the site,P90x dvd.
p90x (Email) (URL) - 05 May '10 - 06:04
Dell inspiron 640m Battery [[http://www.adapterlist.com/dell/inspir..]]laptop battery (Email) (URL) - 14 May '10 - 09:40
Panasonic VW-VBG130 Battery [[http://www.globallaptopbattery.co.uk/c..]]laptop batteries (Email) (URL) - 14 May '10 - 09:42
It is good that we can take the home loans and it opens new opportunities.JacobsShelly (Email) (URL) - 13 June '10 - 17:52
[[http://www.mbtshoeslatest.com]][[http://www.nikeairmaxshoe.com]]
Nike air max shoe (Email) (URL) - 24 June '10 - 07:46
Do you like the ugg ? Ugg Classic Short Boots are UGG Australia’s original heritage styles. Ugg Classic Tall will keep your feet dry and the ultimate comfortable.[[http://www.ugg-boots-london.com/ugg-cl..]]
Ugg Classic Short (Email) (URL) - 07 July '10 - 01:24
The athletic shoes which makes using this technology may the very good local constable convoy mobilization body, Air Max 2009.[[http://www.allhotshoes.com/]]
air max shoes (URL) - 09 July '10 - 05:12